Jason Taylor or Luke Burk to replace BA NOW
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"I get it Pops, i really do, I should be grateful like most here. I have very much been holding my cards very close these last 2 weeks. A comment here or there, but not much after that, solely because I want it to be true that we are improved in all…"
"After a decade under the bush coach many eels fans are still suffering from PTSD and can't let themselves think positively even when positives are obvious to see .
Also the fact that we have had so much false hope over many many years is a…"
Also the fact that we have had so much false hope over many many years is a…"
"I'm optimistic about the style Ryles wants us to play. I think it's effective and suited to the modern game. There's energy and purpose about what we're doing, smart ball movement etc which is very promising however attention to detail needs to be A…"
Replies
JT should've gotten the job in the first place. Unfortunately a certain fuckwit demanded BA.
The same Jason Taylor who was exposed at Souths AND Wests, and who literally no other club in search of a head coach has gone near? Yeah he would have been much better.
Would he be any worse than a coach who has failed to deliver a premiership in 10 years but has delivered a spoon?.
How many other clubs looking for premiership success would be lining up to sign BA once he leaves here?
Yes he would have been worse. He proved that at TWO different clubs. Like it or not, BA has done a decent job at Parra. It's time up? Possibly. But never say that Taylor would have been a better option.
I will say that as it is my opinion.
My opinion also is BA has done a good job getting us off the bottom of the table but he will NEVER be a premiership wining coach.
And I don't disagree that I don't believe that Arthur is the coach to get a premiership. Taylor was a bullet dodged. One that Wests are still recovering from.
Arthur had to deal with the fallout of two major sagas. Taylor wouldn't have. Last year was Arthur's shot to win the comp and he blew it. Albeit, I don't think many teams would have beaten Penrith last year, if any.
Wests had and still have bigger problems than JT.
100%... that was a decade ago
So whk woukdve done a better job at the Tigers, JT or BA ?
Who knows but as you think you're a know it all I'm sure you don't need me to answer that.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 7 Next