I keep repeating that Parry is a development contract player, cannot play NRL until June 30, so after that if he's good enough he should be given the chance to show what he can do, same with at least 3 others.
Sorry, but I don't think Taka has been going too bad at all. He is the least of our problems at present. Even the commentators have been singing his praises. As for suggesting George Jennings? Not on his performance last weekend.
From what I have seen of Taka this year & its been a bit limited but he has not been that bad really, he has lost a bit of pace but defence generally ok but where I have seen him excel has been in the number of High Balls he has jumped over the opponents and gathered the ball in, certainly he was better in those than Fergo at times,
As for George on the wing, he would do best in that spot wearing the Wenty colours, he caused us a lot of grief last year and has continued in the same form, depending on who is available & I read where MJ is trying to be right for the Penrith game, with Sivo back he can go back to Wenty, other option is to keep Hoff in the centres.
Averages 4 fcuk ups a game his inside and outside man have to adjust and compensate for his slow reactions. He bludges. 5 touches a game is pathetic. He is a massive liability in defence due to his lack of speed. No plays involve him they all go too Manu or Marita.
Atm the answer is a resounding YES - Taka is most definitely ahead of anyone else in the centres.
Hoffman has not embarrassed himself in his appearances and surprised me with that 90 metre run, but it ain't broken on Taka's side of the paddock so don't try fixing something that is not a problem.
Fergo is the one on the downhill slide, so if you are looking to replace someone start there.
Electric Eel > Sir Col "THE NODDY MUSHROOM"May 20, 2019 at 8:18pm
Agree with everything mate, but Fergo is very clearly still playing injured and it shows.
"I don't know what you just said.....question is it devastating or not, the discussion echoes around this. Plenty of conspiracy talk, there always will be when you don't know whats behind this process. Personally I am starting to think that Lomax…"
"Incomplete winger who exactly are you replacing this with.
If Lomax is incomplete whats Simonsson or whoever else you replace him with ?
I'm dealing with what I see we are losing too many good players to think roses are red nothing to see here.I see…"
"It's just connections here the guy I know used to play rugby at the same club as I did and his father was the coach of the hurricanes 15 odd years ago when we were playing club rugby and now he's followed in his old man's footsteps.
Mills is the S &…"
"Mate if you think im talking upside youre the complete opposite.
Of course a halves combination takes time to gel. Every team in the comp takes time to gel.. its obiously quicker for established sides but the game is built on your ability to compete…"
Replies
Sorry guys meant to say is Hoffman or George Jennings or Ethan parry a better option with more speed out wide
Adam, you can change the heading if you like.
I keep repeating that Parry is a development contract player, cannot play NRL until June 30, so after that if he's good enough he should be given the chance to show what he can do, same with at least 3 others.
Salmon should play Centre. Put French at 5/8
Sorry, but I don't think Taka has been going too bad at all. He is the least of our problems at present. Even the commentators have been singing his praises. As for suggesting George Jennings? Not on his performance last weekend.
From what I have seen of Taka this year & its been a bit limited but he has not been that bad really, he has lost a bit of pace but defence generally ok but where I have seen him excel has been in the number of High Balls he has jumped over the opponents and gathered the ball in, certainly he was better in those than Fergo at times,
As for George on the wing, he would do best in that spot wearing the Wenty colours, he caused us a lot of grief last year and has continued in the same form, depending on who is available & I read where MJ is trying to be right for the Penrith game, with Sivo back he can go back to Wenty, other option is to keep Hoff in the centres.
EE watch him closely.
Averages 4 fcuk ups a game his inside and outside man have to adjust and compensate for his slow reactions. He bludges. 5 touches a game is pathetic. He is a massive liability in defence due to his lack of speed. No plays involve him they all go too Manu or Marita.
They don't trust him. Say alot really
Taka is a great player we need him in there somewhere
Are you being serious Nathan?
Atm the answer is a resounding YES - Taka is most definitely ahead of anyone else in the centres.
Hoffman has not embarrassed himself in his appearances and surprised me with that 90 metre run, but it ain't broken on Taka's side of the paddock so don't try fixing something that is not a problem.
Fergo is the one on the downhill slide, so if you are looking to replace someone start there.
Agree with everything mate, but Fergo is very clearly still playing injured and it shows.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
of 4 Next