A simple question along the lines of the Hayne or JT blog.... Who would you choose to take us out of the doldrums of the past few seasons if they were both at their peaks..... Both carried the Eels on their backs for a majority of their careers here.... Hindy was my favourite player of all time and Hayne was the best I have ever seen..
Don't forget there was a time when Hindy carried the mantle of "If he's out we can't win" especially in 2005 when he did his knee in rnd 26 when we were minor premiers, that was gonna be our premiership til we got bundled out 29-0 in the Prelim Final by Cowboys.... Hard choice for me but I'd say Hayne slightly.
Replies
Hayne circa 2009 but I also loved Hindy!!
I loved Hindy,Super Bogan to the core,but you can't win a game by tackling alone.At some point a try must be scored.So for me,I'd go with Hayne.
Hayne was the most talented and Hindy had the biggest heart and another 1 was Cayless a workhorse all good captains and Parra champions.
Quit living in the past.
Farken hell. Its like asking someone who you love more Mum or Dad.
Ahh Hayne.
Both freaks of the game in their time, but loyalty prevails and Hayne left so easy one for me.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next