"IF" Thurston was to sign with the eels..

So Parra is apparently looking at JT again. Whether its bullshit or not.
 Its something me and my mates have been saying may happen for a little while. We had massive discussions about the topic  basically stating that , its would cost someone's right testicle to sign JT.
However, with the latest reports stating we are not negotiating mateo,inu,grothe and kk contracts... for the time  being( ive already posted that if warriors offer mateo that 400 a season that he will definitely will go and so to probably eric grothe or take a massive pay cut..), and with cayless probably finishing up this season...
does make you think that it actually isnt such an un acheivable task.
Basiclly its a situation of, 

Mateo   - 230                        Thurston 6-700
Inu        - 220                        resign or sign some back up players. remember we got some
Grothe   - 180                       talent waiting 2 come up and there and jono and shac 
Cayless  - 250
Keating  - 200   
out                                           in

these are obviously not the 100% perfect salary negotiations but im just giving you an idea of the situation if it were to maybe unfold.
Now whether that is warranted is another question. what do u think?
And i am not saying that i do or don't want JT at the club but i have been an advocate in saying and some will know this from other posts, that parra have a frustrating habit of spreading the money to the wrong parts of the field, and not putting the cash on the players who should be the highest payed, out 679 and 1 we got the 1 right. 
Our 679 always seem to be mediocre or potentials but.. we do the opposite to melbourne, they get their team spine solid as a rock and then build outwards from that. 

Im not saying our halves or hookers arent good, but lets face it , we haven't won anything since sterling left, made two gf's since and both times the opposing no.7 has dominated over us the whole game ( Cronk and Joey). 
Maybe it is time to get the best halfback in the blue and gold number 7 jersey again instead of always trying our luck for up and comers and promising talents. coz they just arent paying off. parra have tripled what they would have to pay for JT in previous number 7's that have got us nowhere. We will also loose the " hes the next sterlo" stigma that gets attached to every young halve we bring up or buy. Because JT has already established his reputation. He is the worlds best half back and the Australian Half back. The pressure to be the next sterlo then also disappears.

Now i actually want us to play kk and mortimer and i think that combo has huge POTENTIAL.
It is however interesting thought as to what parra would be capable if we started building our squad as a team that melbourne do and actually have our best players in the needed positions.  HAYNE, MORTIMER, THURSTON .. not bad. This is obviously speculation so im looking for thoughts to if it would be warranted to lose the players for jt or if it would work at all.
Go the eels

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Thurston's talents are on the decline in my opinion. He's still better than most number 7's for sure, but I'd baulk at paying 600-700K for him. 500K would be tops. If there was a number 7 in the comp I'd love to go for and who wouldn't be asking for anywhere near what Thurston wants it'd be Cronk. I'd take him in a heartbeat. That guy turns up giving 100% EVERY week, never less.
  • Perfectly sumed up.
  • i would buy thurston and let mateo and inu go any day of the week.

    I would like to retain keating and grothe though on reduced contract (approx $120k each)
  • I will add some more thoughts later, but the immediate thought I have is God help JT if we do sign him and we lose 3 in a row! ;)
  • We cant afford to lose 4-5 players to sign 1!!!

    We need to fit 25 players under our cap.

    We currently have little to no room to move, so its all good and well to say "let go of Mateo, Inu, Grothe, KK and Cayless" but he will take up ALL their salarys and we still need 4 more players!!
  • hahah very true
  • We need to let a few players go and then make a play for any good halfback that will take 300-400k
  • surely Cayless is on more than 250. i'd say the figure is closer to 400. losing cayless and inu would get us thurston. inu is on around 250 from memory. i visited family in Townsville on the weekend and went to the cowboys v titans game. Thurston was oustanding. he was everywhere in attack and didn't mss anything in defence. i say copy the storm's way of thinnking. have quality 1679, speedy back backs, big props and a mobile back row.
  • Thurston is the best number 7 in the world i would pay him $1,000,000 a season.He will make paul carige look like a superstar if he was playing outside him.
  • Mate if you had your way, there would be Johnathan Thurston and about three others in the team. That's all we could affford. I don't think that will work somehow.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Bup replied to Eels2025's discussion Jake Averillo & Josh Kerr
"I wanted us to have a crack at Adam Elliot, Roosters and Souths are after him, looks like it'll be at the Roosters.
Word is Radleys done"
50 minutes ago
Kenny Power replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Canterbury hooker Reed Mahoney to join Cowboys on long-term deal
"If he wasnt released mid season , they would have tried very hard for next year. Have a feeling that's why richo released him early so dogs couldn't get him as they would have no cap or spots for this year"
1 hour ago
Hector replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Canterbury hooker Reed Mahoney to join Cowboys on long-term deal
"Well if that's the case we shouldn't have signed him hey . What the stuff are we talking about the dogs and Reed for .Anyway We got DaSiilva end of story and the Dogs didn't. Happy Days"
1 hour ago
macybrown replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Canterbury hooker Reed Mahoney to join Cowboys on long-term deal
"Reckon that's a good point you making there Byron ...I think it would've been extremely touch and go. Sounds like dogs stuffed up a bit hehe
I'd like to think it's good timing Reed!"
1 hour ago
More…