Replies

  • It isn't confirmed and just like rumours on here probably based on nothing other than someone's imagination. 

    Even if it is true how do you know we didn't chase them but they chose the dogs.  Signing players isn't just about money offered there plenty of other factors.

  • To two tough no holds barred footballers . Would have been good pick ups . 

     

    We are are so inactive In player recruitment . If we are active we are very unsuccessfulat actually snaring decent players . 

    • Or maybe we are concentrating on internal improvement ?

      • I hope your way of the mark.

        • Why ?

          Don't you want to see our players improve ?

          Recruitment is not the only way to improve the team.

  • This reply was deleted.
    • But, how effective will they be away from the Melbourne system ?

      Honestly, name one player Melbourne have let walk who gets better at another club ?

      • This reply was deleted.
        • He hasn’t gotten better, but he didn’t leave for more money anyway. 

          • This reply was deleted.
            • He's a good player, so is Welch, but their value is inflated because they play in the Melbourne system with Cam Smith & Munster.

              Now if those two were coming with him ....

      • Inglis, Gareth Widdop, james Maloney, Israel Folau, Matt Orford

        • James Maloney barely played in Melbourne, Gareth Widdop didn't get better, he just got more opportunity, Izzy definitely didn't get better, certainly not the Broncos, Matt Orford was in the early days of Craig Bellamy's reign, and GI's best years were in Melbourne.

           

           

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Coryn Hughes replied to Eelawarra's discussion EELS COACH JASON RYLES PUSHED TO SIGN OFF ON ZAC LOMAX’S RELEASE REQUEST - THIS IS WHY
"You know what grinds me the most HoE and I apologise for my response but this FO just frustrate me they really do because I understand what we are up against and when they say trust in JR I actually do I think he's been great for Parra great.
BUT…"
2 minutes ago
LB replied to ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER's discussion Who are we going to buy
"The mistake they made was hiring Meninga as opposed to hiring someone like BA or Holbrook. Here me out, Perth needed a coach that could handle the media and pressure of a new franchise. Be able to find diamonds in the rough and producing a somewhat…"
16 minutes ago
LB replied to ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER's discussion Who are we going to buy
"$1.2mil for Campbell. I mean he is a fine player but wow that is a massive over pay. "
25 minutes ago
LB replied to ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER's discussion Who are we going to buy
"Well let's hope that means we are going for Taulagi instead to replace Lomax if we are going to market."
26 minutes ago
More…