Hypothetical second-rower?

Given Nathan Hindmarsh is departing as well as likely Shane Shackleton, I find it hard to believe we won't pick up one or at least two second rowers and I feel very strongly we're missing a really top class, proven edge runner, and that's pretty apparent for everyone to see.

So I'm going to keep my unicorn-horn rimmed glasses on, and believe these is a trump card that is going  to be played. Problem is I can't figure out who the hell it might be? Manu was my last shot.

I've looked through the English Super League, I've thought about other codes and I just can't think of any player, outside of Williams who might fit the bill. And I keep getting told we've never even spoken to him. Maybe a player on contract at another club, who might for some reason be looking for release?

My brain is hurting. Can anyone come up with a theory outside of Williams?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Been mentioned twice over a few months on NRL Rumors that we are keen to get Jeremy Smith from Cronulla.

     

    I read that Cronulla were not expecting Topou to act on an option in his favour and perhaps that see's the shark's needing to shop Smith around?

    • I wouldn't mind Smith, as long as he doesn't cost us too much. How is Glen Morrison going at Super League?

    • I believe Smith was also linked to us last time he was off contract, but ended up signing with Cronulla. Pretty sure he's still contracted for next season but I'd have him in the side in a second. Tough, aggressive and knows how to find the line.

  • why dont we look at importing a couple of young tough pommy second rowers........? do any of you guys see the super league much to suggest a few names.

    • True, we better start looking overseas.

  • It is strange..  generally anyone who is 'available' is shopped around the media by their agents.  Or at least shopped around to other clubs, resulting in it leaking to the media.

    We even heard about the likes of Graham going to Bulldogs long before it actually happened.

    I'm at a loss.

  • What's your take on a player like Chris Houston, Joel Edwards, Ukuma Ta'ai or Jake Marketo, Phil?
    A few back-rowers that are off-contract at season's end for their respective teams. 

    • None of them are really attacking second rowers except for maybe Marketo, but being a rookie, meh.

      Edwards would be alright.

      Need SBW.

  • The problem is we have so many second rowers on contract, just not a top class one. 

    Maitua

    Smith

    Paulo

    Horo

    Lasalo

    Ryan

    POH

    Brien

    Penese

    Loko (after two knee constructions may come back as an edge second rower?)

    Are all in our top squad I believe.

    I think Lussick may be an option as a number 12? He has the aggression, size, speed and footwork if Nolan and Kearney are confident they could make use of him a little wider. Loko might be a wild-card depending on how is physique is after the off-season.

    Next year I reckon we have 

    11. ???

    12. Ben Smith

    13. Maitua

    15. Paulo/Ryan

    locked in. Jeremy Smith at 13 might be a good option (if he really will break contract?). 

    A possibility may be Ukuma Tai (sp?) from the Warriors? Taumololo should have been ideal. I don't reckon we have the cap space to pay 600k for a second rower which is why i'm not surprised we dropped out of the running for T-Rex (as much as i would have loved to have him). 

    Gavin Cooper would be a cheap signing who would get the job done as well if we're desperate.

    Edit: Just read Ricky's comment, Houston or Edwards would also be decent signings imo. 

    • Matt Ryan is not a bench player. He will be our long term 2nd rower for years to come. If he is going this good now the sky's the limit for him next year
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin replied to Archie's discussion Warriors injustice?
"Im going there Wiz. 1 hr full body thx mate"
6 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to CarloEEL2's discussion It’s a no from the red bandana
"Name the crazy claims I've made, Wiz. My bet is you can't. Put differently, you don't grasp points made but instead of just trying harder it's "that's crazy". "
6 minutes ago
LB replied to Parra-all-the-way's discussion Jesse McLean a bulldog
"We did go for him? It was news months ago. I mean sure handy for us but also Penrith have refused to use him and he has been in top 30 for 3 years? For us could have been a nice player to have and see how he went but also could have been same as…"
19 minutes ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Archie's discussion Warriors injustice?
"Theyll have you believe he's actually coaching then now and Holbrooks just the bloke fronting the media .  
What about old Woolfy got his Phin up 
 
 "
29 minutes ago
More…