He doesn't have the creativity to play 6. Who knows maybe with a bit of training he may become an ok 6, but not full time. Honestly (excuse the profile pic) French is my choice for 1 over Gutherson. Leaving centre and wing for him to play.
Gutherson is a valuable player to have due to his versatility. Playing every position in the backline, as well giving his all every 80mins adds value even to a struggling line-up. Although I see any real insane talent that leads to people saying that's why he is the real deal. With French its his composure, quickness, competitiveness that makes him a threat. Gutherson isn't very fast, can struggle under pressure and is competitive however.
My opinion Norman will stay, and Robson will partner him. We can win a comp with those halves. Robson is not the problem, neither is Gutherson. Neither has great creativity or a good kicking game. They were thrown into this situation with staff saying "Off you go". But even with this situation, Gutherson shows that he is a good stop gap at best. Robson is also a stop gap, however he is a better half than Gutherson, well at least for now.
Not saying he will never play good at 6, he may need time. But with this line-up I think we will win more games with Robson than Gutherson. Happy to be proven wrong but that's what I think
Replies
Its time to experiment.
I reckon anyone who is left in the top 25 will get a run for the rest of the year. John Falou will be the first.
I would be asking the NRL for some dispensation to play some young kids like dargan just to see how they go.
Everything is geared towards next year.