Replies

  • Going for a stab in the dark, Justin Poore and Shane Shackleton. Both half arsed 2011, one was gone for 2012 and bad mouthed SK, while the other hardly played in 2012.

  • I'd throw Fui into the mix as a potential candidate. Maybe Carl Webb , but I do like your guess of Poore and Shackleton.  I'll ask Poore next time I see him at the Burgh Pub.

  • I'd probably say Shackleton, Allgood or Webb. Our roster was so bad back then like. I remember before the season began they showed a picture of our signings, Waitura, Webb, Chris Walker, Casey Maguire, Chris Hicks lol. Not only that, you had Stephen Kearney who had the personality of a wet dishcloth, one of the worst rugby league head coaches of the modern era.

    • I wouldn't say Allgood, more so due to the fact he started in Round 1 out of nowhere. Unless this one incident is an outlier and he fixed up his act after, coaches at times are not as forgiving. Someone like say Fui could do this and still play round 1 due to his stature. Allgood though? Hadn't even debuted until Round 1 that year, so if it was him Kearney would have gave him more time in reserve grade.

      Webb is a decent shout. Whatuira also, only played 1 game for us.

  • Hayne 

    • Wouldn't shock me. But imagine how much of a hater you'd be labeled on here back then if you dared question the messiahs ethics and commitment  😂😂. 

      Oh that's right , I did.

  • I'd say Hayne or Ben Smith most likely one of the already mentioned Poore/Shackleton 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

iamnot replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Michael Ennis sucking the c** of Dylan Brown
"He lasted two years of that supposed 8 year deal. It was never an 8 year deal. "
14 minutes ago
iamnot replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Michael Ennis sucking the c** of Dylan Brown
"The quality of the game has certainly gone downhill if Brown is in the running for the Golden Boot. "
16 minutes ago
SuperEel 22 replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Michael Ennis sucking the c** of Dylan Brown
"Brown's in the conversation for Golden Boot this year. NZ have a great forward pack and they provide a ball runner like Brown the space and time to do his thing. Newcastle have a pop gun set of middles that can barely hold the ball."
32 minutes ago
KENDOZA replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Michael Ennis sucking the c** of Dylan Brown
"Big difference when playing test footy. Samoa were bog average in the second half. Lets see how he goes behind the knights pack lol."
46 minutes ago
More…