Get Carter?

Roosters to cut Carter

With the current dearth in quality available hookers is Paul Carter a viable option to seek redemption under BA or is he too much trouble to even consider?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I've seen him play for Wyong this season and he is a step above at ISP level, the best forward for Wyong, which are at the top of the table.  From what I have seen of him he is more of a runner then defender and is probably more suited to the backrow then hooker.  But as he is a small backrower he is too small to play in the backrow in the NRL week in week out.  Although, as he has a decent pass he could convert to a fulltime NRL hooker/Utility.  He is better then King, but I don't think he is better then Kaysa at this point in time.  Is he too much of a goose, no.   

    • It sounds like the roosters are over him and wouldn't mind him gone asap. Playing long minutes each week is going to takes its toll on Kayser eventually. He really puts his body on the line. If he goes down for a few weeks we have King and Will Smith as backups.
      Considering his current status at the roosters he might provide some cheap insurance. It appears BA loves a bit of Moneyball and could be seen as a calculated risk if we got him at a bargain basement price. His utility as a backrower makes him a decent bench option.

  • Nnnnnnnnoooooo
  • Griffin has been extended by Gus
    Maybe Wallace wants out?
    • Wallace is injured
  • This reply was deleted.
    • Ive been reading the same over on the roosters forum, apparently this guy has burnt his bridges there, theres talk of him turning up to training drunk and not turning up at all and having a poor attitude off the park, hes been through a few clubs now and the same things happened at each one

  • Wouldn't mind him off the bench. Can fill in at dummy half and play backrow. Next year given the supposed top 30, the more players with utility value outside of your top 17 the better off squads will be.
    • Agreed Ham. I think a utility is what we need rather than a replacement for Kaysa. Someone to take some of the load but leaving Kaysa there to develop further.
  • Prichard is better than carter, infact the last couple of weeks he has been outstanding, the search for a no 9 is over, BA is doing a geeat Job with Prichard he is improving every week, Kaysa,s stats speak for themselves, Not bad for a park footballer
    and a bush coach!
    • Apart from the fact that Kaysa is 3rd in most tackles made in the premiership, I was really impressed with his run down on Crichton. Not only does he catch him and make the tackle, he gave his right arm an almighty whack to dislodge the ball. That showed me that he is smart as he knew the tackle wasnt going to be enough. I rated Guth as fast be he was smoked and gave the chase up quickly.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Muttman replied to Rabz S's discussion Parramatta Eels extend Josh Addo-Carr
"Great stuff. JAC's contract has been handled perfectly. A one year plus club option to see how he'd perform. JAC played exceptionally well and now we give him 2 more years. Well played everyone. "
2 seconds ago
CarloEEL2 replied to Rabz S's discussion Parramatta Eels extend Josh Addo-Carr
"Every Parra fan would be ecstatic with this news !!! I was iffy initially with the signing but the fox has totally bought into the club and shown more passion for the jumper in a season than many long term players imo 💛💙💛💙"
7 minutes ago
DYNASTY.LOADING replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Cooper Cronk: On the Parramatta Eels, Pezet, Lomax and Recruitment
"Hey mate I don't think I've gathered your opinion on Lincoln? Sometimes I think we overlook that we have the schoolboys 7 here. In your opinion was he deserving of that appointment? Or was it more there wasn't much competition for the jersey? 
I…"
59 minutes ago
Darren Munro replied to Eelawarra's discussion NRL LEGENDS EXPLAIN HOW TERRIFYING STEVE ELLA WAS
"Didn't realise he had drop foot. Exceptional player."
1 hour ago
More…