Legends,
To kick off my rebirth, Id love to see a bit of discord discussing our strongest 17 for this year.
I have a suggestion listed below:
Grand Final Team 2022
1. Gutherson
2. Waqa
3. Penisini
4. Niukore
5. Sivo
6. DBrown
7. Moses
8. Paulo
9. Mahoney
10. RCG
11. Lane
12. Papalii
13. Matterson
14. Russel
15. Makatoa
16. NBrown
17. Kaufusi
A bit of an interesting suggestion so more than happy to have a bit of a discussion regarding the side.
I think Marata didnt miss a beat when filling in at Centre when needed.
Starting him in the backs would be giving us a much needed boost out of the redzone.
I think this could really help out our forwards.
Carrying an extra outside back on the bench could help us with injury coverage or a shift to a different play style.
That being said, if Stone was healthy he would be my 14.
I think this set up could help us keep our best players on the park for longer.
Waqa can come into his familiar Centre role, DB Can fill in at Hooker, Russel can cover at Fullback, Marata second row.
Let me know what you think, would love to chat about it :)
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
Replies
Maybe Russell wing Nikure 14 Waqa 4
I think Waqa is a better winger than Russel.
Russel is obviously an awesome player, I just think the returns coming out of the redzone are so critical, he has a lightweight frame.
If Marata is full strength I think we want him out there for as long as possible. We have seen how hard it is to get a forward 'into the game' as it goes by. We would be making the most out of Papalii too, who is an 80 minute player.
BA hasnt been the only coach to hold back on using one of his players throughout the 80 minutes.
Nice team, Jed. Looks very strong defensively.
Can see a justification for Niukore at centre, but can also see one for Waqa at centre & Russell or Simmonson on wing. It's a tough one, Waqa was playing so well on the wing.
Simonsson has the wing spot locked up.
when waqa returns he will go into the centres with penisini. That leaves sivo or russel as the only other wing spot.
I like matterson in 13. He can play the full 80 and I've said for a few years that nbrown should come off the bench despite him making me eat my words in quite a few performances, but lately he looks slow and has a terrible play the ball. shaun lane has a fantastic offload in him and has points around him, but his is a slug sometimes.
marata on the bench to cover second row and centres. JA as the utility :)
I really like the starting side. Not convinced I'd leave out Simmonson though. He has been very good recently. I think our right side attack is under utilised generally, which makes us biased towards Simmonson's value/ contribution. If he had scored a few more tries, I think everyone would be sold on him. However, he doesn't get much good ball on the try line because we seem to favour our left side attack. For example, we often see the cut out ball gift the left winger easy tries, but that almost never happens on the right - which is a little ironic considering Moses plays on the right.
I'd probably keep Nuikore on the bench with N Brown and Kaufusi. For the 14, I'd go with Perham or Carty. I'd lean towards Perham, but only if we trialled him there beforehand playing that middle 14 role like Dylan Walker does for Manly. I think Perham has the agility and hands to do it, but I'd like to see him prove it before picking him there for a big game.
i would have w blake centre and move niukore to 17 and simonsson or russell on wing as they are natural wingers then carty or opacic at 14. kaufusi to 18
1: C Gutherson
2: M Sivo
3: W Penisini
4: B Simonson
5: W Blake
6: D Brown
7: M Moses
8: Jr Paulo
9: R Mahoney
10: RCG
11: S Lane
12: I Papali
13: R Matterson
14: H Perham ( covers 1-7 )
15: N Brown
16: M Makatoa
17: M Nuikore
18th B Cartwright
id put Blake on wing, he Carries the ball back hard and fast, Simonson played centre at the raiders and was good
Perham covers the whole backline if there's an injury
1. Gutho
2. Sivo
3. Penisini
4. Opacic
5. Blake
6. D Brown
7. Moses
8. Paulo
9. Mahoney
10. RCG
11. Lane
12. Niukore
13. Matterson
14. Perham
15. N Brown
16. Papali'i
17. Kaufusi
I wouldnt mind Simonsson into the centers -> not sure what his passing game is like or ability to defend in the centres but physically looks more suited there IMO
Not a dig at his performances on the wing, just more a comment about his size
Waqa much more of a natural winger judging by size and athletic ability
I'd have Cartwright on the bench. Seems like no else trusts him lol tho lol. Also don't get the knock on his D when the knock on him back on the day was forcing the offload.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next