French to 5/8 gutho to FB?

Hiya all I don't know if this has had its own discussion before so I apologise if so...is there any reason why French couldn't be 5/8 and gutho FB? From what I heard French has played a lot of playmaker in the lower grade and gutho is a FB naturally. Take into that frenchs size and wouldn't he be a better fit if we were grooming someone alongside Norman for 5(8? I understand there is a lot of pressure associated with the role but gutho is also quite young himself???

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I definitely think French would make a good half, from the moment i saw him its the first thing i thought, this guy should be in the halves im just not sure hes ready for it at this stage of his career but it can be done, look at lockyer all be it he was a solid defender for a half..

    • Thinking the same, he's not ready. If you throw him in now, he'll become rocks and diamonds like Shaun Johnston.
  • Possibly down the track i think beven strength is in his running game particularly support play and broken play i think this will make him better suited to fullback at this point pf his career
  • Defence is Gutherdon's best asset and French's worst. This means we would prefer Gutherson attempting 20 tackles per game than French. As for the fullback needing to be good because he's the last line of defence, it's true, but for a position that only attempts a couple of tackles per game it's still less important. How often do fullbacks save tries from a tackle? A couple of times a season? Most often the attacker draws the fullback and passes. Anyway French is okay at tackling the legs, which he can do at fullback. Up in the line you need to wrap up the ball. Gutherson is great at this.
    • I know M Gordon saved a lot more than two last year
  • Definitely, if not late this year, then in 2018/2019 it will happen.
  • I've been saying this for some time, Baron but the usual pundits jump up and down with the predictable, "French can't defend well enough for the halves" etc.
    I still maintain that with a bit more work on his defence, he would kill it at half. He needs the ball in his hands more than at fullback. He is a talent and has a killer passing game.
    Gutho is a fullback...end of story.
    • I agree Gutherson is a fullback (or centre) but French is not suited to the halves. His strength is his running game. That means he needs space, and he won't get that in the halves.
  • No.... Bev is not a 6 he is a 1! As for Gutho I told people on here 6months ago he isn't a five-eight everyone told me I was silly now after the 9's everyone is like ohh he isn't a ball player blah blah blah..... mate I told everyone that 6months ago, Clint is DREADFUL, Shit kicking game, no balls skills.

    6 Norman
    7 Forgarty
    • Loving the use of 18 minutes in a 9's format without your dominant halves partner is the best evidence you guys can put forward.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Hell On Eels replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Cooper Cronk: On the Parramatta Eels, Pezet, Lomax and Recruitment
"HFK, Fair point. Sure, we could. But balancing incoming youth with experience is almost a perennial issue. A constant cycle. It never really goes away. At least not for too long. "
2 hours ago
Cumberland Eel replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion New signing at training ??? New guy
"Don't rate him at all . Still needs time in lower grades "
3 hours ago
Gaz Nelson replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion New signing at training ??? New guy
"Good to see players are finally free to get around in their sports bras with Brown out of the picture. 
 "
4 hours ago
Acme replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion New signing at training ??? New guy
"Joash definitely did"
6 hours ago
More…