Anyone watch the Panthers saints game.   Cleary put on a shoulder charge that made saints lose ball and the Panthers scored on the same play.

The commentators called shoulder charge as it happened but after the try was scored were very quiet about it.  1 replay showed clearly a shoulder charge but yet again no blasting the refs or bunker and bunker didn't call it back and they just moved on despite clear evidence.

Now if that was any other team Parra included you can guarantee commentators blow up and complain for next few minutes and show replay after replay, or if it happened the other way around it would be pulled up for further review by the bunker.

It will be interesting to see what match review committee say or charge as Cleary has priors for shoulder charges as well.  Not a high grade offence but by charging Cleary they will have to admit the bunker didn't do its job pulling it back as no try.

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • 9419231658?profile=RESIZE_930x

    • To not even call time off and have a better look was a disgrace.  He clearly tucked his arm in as seen in photo.

  • Nathan Brown probably gets a week for that!

  • Nothing new, media and ref bias has been happening for forever and a day. Parra need to figure out how they get in on the game 

  • What about last night when the Storm's challenge was unsuccesful but then they got to challenge again?

  • What a disgrace that penalty was in the roosters game that handed them the win. How can you challenge a mistake your team made and get a penalty for the previous play?, surely that's outside the rule.

    • Fucking disgrace HKF...

      It's only a matter of time before a GF gets decided by a bullshit call like that.

      Henry Perenara full-time in the bunker...enough said.

    • Broncos were the better team and deserved the win but the NRL wasn't having any of it.

      • I'm 100% convinced the roosters are just making up the numbers come finals time, they are one of the teams i am reasonably confident we can beat if we are at full strength minus mahoney. 

        • We certainly need to play a lot better than we did last time we played them or we be fooked.

          In all honesty on current form the Broncos would have beaten us tonight had we played them.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Prof. Daz replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Triple M - eels not fazed if Lomax leaves.
"Does anyone give any credibility to reports the Eels would "not be fazed" if Lomax left? Lomax made SOO and the Kangaroos (before withdrawing), is in the Top 20 metres per game and runs per game, is a first or second choice goal kicker, can play…"
34 seconds ago
HKF replied to Troy Wade's discussion Round 1 v Storm
"What people need to keep in mind is the whole draw isn't generated by AI or any other means, certain games such as eels v tigers Easter Monday, Anzac weekend and such are predetermined. There is probably a whole bunch of games and predetermined…"
2 hours ago
Poppa replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Triple M - eels not fazed if Lomax leaves.
"Beautiful rhetoric Adam...../you miss the point about him being irreplaceable."
2 hours ago
Poppa replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Triple M - eels not fazed if Lomax leaves.
"Who is not phased? nobody who has an understanding of what he offers, which means it is not the coaches.
Eli republishing this shit is what we have talked about before!"
2 hours ago
More…