EVERY PLAYER RATED /10

1. Norman 6/102. French 2/103. Takarangi 1/104. Michael 1/105. George 5/106. Gutherson 4/107. Moses 0/108. Alvaro 6/109. King 2/1010. Vave 2/1011. Mau 5/1012. Moeroa 5/1013. Terepo 4/1014. Smith 1/1015. Matagi 4/1016 gower 5/1017 niukore 4/10Arthur and the staff 0/10

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Mau, alvaro, Norman all played solid games.
  • Bit harsh on Moeroa, he had his best game for a long time.

    Brad Arthur has finally worked out that he's not a middle forward.

    • He'd score an 8 if we won. Unfortunately i cant see how anyone could score more than a 6/10 in a losing side
      • It's not as though they lost by 50.

        Reality is they lacked direction and attacking flair from the key positions ie. Moses, Gutherson, Norman and King.

    • Doesnt matter if we lose by 50 or by 2

      We didnt get the two points for the tenth week this year so they deserve these ratings.

      I agree we lack direction thats why moses got a 0. He was the dominant half tonight and did nothing
  • Maybe a touch harsh on Jenko... but overall, yep, pretty close to the mark I'd say.

    Harsh on BA & co though - you weren't impressed with 2 pretend hookers on the field at once while Niukore gets splinters? Taking the 2 when down by 8 near the end? Zero by way of set plays and attacking structure inside the 20? A completely soft middle? No grunt coming off our line? There was some coaching mastery out there tonight.

    We all understand it is easier said than done but man, we so need an overhead projector session again!

    • The old projector session.

      Ricky Stuart did the club a favour before he left yet Arthur who came in with a clean slate has stuffed it up again!

  • You're 1-2 points under for each player. 3 points short for Tepai
    • In my view you lose 1-2 points if you dont win the game. No player can be an 8/10 in a losing side unless they absolutely carried the whole team which no one did tonight.

      A 5/10 rating for moeroa is fair. He was good tonight and will be better with a new coach guiding him
  • can you deduct 4 from mau for missed tackle
    and 1 each from terepo and gower knock on please

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Prof. Daz replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Trial #2 / Pre Season Challenge Week 3 Team List v Sydney Roosters
"I'm with you, Blue Eel. It's boom or bust for Ryles. I say that not because it's fair that a second year coach is expected to get the team into the finals and strongly compete for top honours. It's probably not. But the Eels have been so starved of…"
22 minutes ago
Hell On Eels replied to Hell On Eels's discussion The Eels v Lomax: Timeline and Key Questions
"Ironically, around 13 Jan, when Storm agreed to pay Lomax's legal fees (could cause cap implications) was also when Tripp allegedly called Beach to threaten that the Eels could be hit with cap sanctions by the NRL.
 
NRL.com official salary cap…"
51 minutes ago
Flow Basket replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Trial #2 / Pre Season Challenge Week 3 Team List v Sydney Roosters
"Kicker that's easy Russell "
1 hour ago
Blue Eel replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Lomax legal promise could create salary-cap headache for Storm
"Dont you love a feel good story !
Love that if Melbourne were to win and Lomax's contract with the Storm was confirmed, the fact that Lomax's legal bills would go on top of their salary cap even though they don't have that cap space is just…"
1 hour ago
More…