Eels join Bulldogs for the signature of Brent Naden. Thoughts??
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"No it is relevant. You have a weaker conference, average teams get more points against much weaker teams. If you have a team with more wins but the other team gets higher seed or makes finals due to bonus wins that's not fair. They get the bonus…"
"
Having 1 conference stronger than another would matter at all. The extra points for conference wins are only available in your own conference, therefore the strength or weakness of your conference is irrelevant. The downside I see with the…"
Having 1 conference stronger than another would matter at all. The extra points for conference wins are only available in your own conference, therefore the strength or weakness of your conference is irrelevant. The downside I see with the…"
"Ok but firstly SL clubs would get annoyed those players can't stay. Players get annoyed they get shafted for NRL players. For 3 weeks not worth the while to get hurt. Paid extra money yet the game loses money with less product as stated before.…"
"The more points is not fair as not both conferences are the same in quality. What if one conference is more difficult than the other? Plus the 3 higher ranked doesn't solve the issue of worse teams still getting in over better teams simply due to…"
Replies
My thoughts are that a combo of Blake and Naden in the centres is going to leak a shit load of points. I'm only on board if the idea is to move Blake on with the thought that nadens defence can be improved
I thought we would've learned our lesson about Penrith centers
So we should never again sign a center from the panthers?
lol
Im not sure this will be too good for club PR, especially with the female fans..
Somebody always has to be woke about the good ideas.
Sign him up asap.
With him And Cartwright I guess we don't have a no dickheads policy
Please no. Send him to south's with his brothers
No thanks
There is obviously a shortage of quality centres around at the moment.
I have a feeling or should I say understanding why Parra would chase Naden, I am just not convinced about him as being the quality required and that's not going near the point of his character being good enough.
Point 1 convince ourselves he is good enough
Point 2 assuming he passes point one, where is he mentally with regards to his life and football future.
I understand Galgai is available, I would go after him before Naden and whilst 3 years may see him out, those 3 years are capably filled and gives us room to reassess as we go along.
I do believe Galgai is a much more mature footballer and provides leadership, whereas you may not have said the second portion 2 or 3 years back.
PS Galgai has also won a premiership and such experience is invaluable with our ambitions and when you think about it a perfect replacement for Mennings. i.e. like for like
It's a no from me. His defence is not great and he is one of those players that always seems to have unnecessary niggle in his game, similar to Latrell, that I hate seeing. Say no to dickheads.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next