Ok so would not take too much out of this as it is a no name outlet reporting. However, since it involves Parramatta and im bored lets discuss for fun anyway. This report states Brisbane are keen to get both Maika Sivo and Clint Gutherson, with Brisbane offering a package deal in return. Not sure what value they get since Brisbane is strong in their backline nor need a Fullback with Walsh there already. Let's say this is true, doubt it is but argument sakes lets go with it, they could use a Centre Brisbane and leadership as to where Gutho comes in. As for Sivo, yeah that is an odd one since they have Mariner and Cobbo already. Added to that, I do not see how these two would help Brisbane, Walters is definately feeling the pressure in general. He ain't going to last much longer with Brisbane's high expectation as being a powerhouse, missing the 8 in 3 of his 4 seasons he is in trouble. Can we take advantage of that? haha
But what would you take in a package deal for those two from Brisbane. Blake Mozer would be one considering Billy Walters is the proposed Hooker at the moment. Mariner definately, of course they wont let him go but worth a try. Perhaps Hetherington or Willison also?
All a bit of fun to think about if it were to be true.
Replies
Yeh! i will play the game and I agree withyour log but I would want Katoni Staggs and Jessie Arthurs in my swap.
Staggs doesn't look comfoertable to me and he is a NSW player. Jessie is just a good player with genuine speed. Changes our backline to a completely different shape. How happy is Gutho given the disrespect he gets from some. That said Talagi is not his natural replacement.
Please poppa, haven't the club had enough Arthur's? Like mick said the club needs to exorcise the kellyville training paddocks of every last Arthur.
This is an Arthars not Arthur. The 'S' on the end surely can form a disconnect Chief?
It's too close call LB it's a no from me lol
I guess one thing that would not be great is Jesse Arthars would be initialled JA on this site. PTSD will reappear for some even more so.
Chief we should send pops to the re education camp as well - the BA era has affected supporters and fans alike
I agree, something about him at the moment shows he looks a bit lost at Brisbane, just cannot seem to get going consistently. He might want a change in scenary.
Another kid i would look at is Israel Leota, just a better version of Greg Marzhew.
I'd take Mozer. Far too much upside in him. It's unlikely but if we're taking Mozer he has a great combination with Ben Te Kura so we could grab him too.
So they grab our most experienced and best effort player. Also possibly the best finisher in the league. We get 2 reserve graders. JR must have his eyes on a few from the Broncos.
Throw in Paulo and Lane.. we get Haas - Carrington - Staggs - Arthurs
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
of 4 Next