Dylan Brown as Hooker

Just wondering what 1EEs think of DB as hooker. Not suggesting a change as he is killing it as 5:8 and our best option there. Don't think he should be moved unless we had a better option. But for example in the unlikely event Ethan Sanders or another of our upcoming halves started showing promise as an elite half over the next three years then maybe it would justify considering changing our halves pair. Dylan seems to love playing in the middle and is a great defender. He seems happy not being the dominant play maker most of the time. He would be good at darting out of dummy half. Main issues is his passing off the ground is poor, but with a few years practice that could be improved. Personally can't see DB playing FB or outside back but he may enjoy hooker. Not sure if being hooker would mean we could not utilise his step as much as when he is wider but maybe it would give him more opportunity.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • No, just no. His great strength is running the ball against a stretched defence. 

    • Yeah was worried about that but he is strong and middles often don't have good lateral movement - cook gets lots of opportunities down the middle

      • He's at his best attacking the edges. Would Bellamy move Munster to 9 ?

        • i am not saying DB should move to 9. I am saying he may make a good hooker and if we got a really good half coming  up through the grades then it may be an option. But that half would have to be better than DB and Moses. I do not see Ethan Sanders as better but that may change. Same for Munster. If Bellamy had a better half prospect coming through then moving munster to dummy half could be consisdered but that half would have to be better than Munster to warant it. That is why I was against moving DB to accomadate JA when DB was a better half prospect

          • I know what you meant but we have a couple of young prospects coming through the grades with Yates and now Hands as the #1 with Hodgson as your mentor.There stacked for the next 3-4 yrs with prospects who have a chance to jump up.

            Sanders is a good prospect no doubt but he isn't getting his shot here for at least another 3-4 seasons.The club have made it clear that as long as MM and DB are around they'll be the combo over that time.The club has been very clear with that.

            Sanders will no doubt be plying his trade else where in a halves starved league.With Asi also signed for another 2 yrs also bares this out.

    • If anything, centre would really suit him. Great defender and strong one-on-one in attack.

      Penisini would make a great hooker. Built low, strong powerful legs out of dummy half. 

      • but can he kick

         

  • No.

  • Nope, fullback when Gutho is past it.

    • Maybe I am blind but I can't see DB as FB. Can't see him organising the defence and not sure what is backing up in attack would be like - does he have the fitness for FB?

      Plus he seems to like being at the front and middle in the thick of it

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

BEM replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Houston In Hindsight: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
"Great write up once again HOE.

R10: Broncos at Commbank
R11: Storm at Suncorp
R12: Rabbits at Accor
R13: Sharks at Commbank
R14: Dogs at Accor
R15: Roosters at Commbank

I honestly can't see where a win will come in the next 6 weeks.
I see us…"
1 hour ago
Bob Smith replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Houston In Hindsight: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
"Crikey, we're stuffed. Defence worse than the spoon years. That hurts. F u BA. "
2 hours ago
Frank The Tank replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Houston In Hindsight: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
"That's my concern too.
A few wins and suddenly all is well according to the board and then they extend BA for a few more years.
Rinse repeat and the problem will continue with no end in sight."
3 hours ago
Tad replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Houston In Hindsight: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
"Age of players seems to be a factor in a lot of discussion. Bennett is a smart guy by having the foresight and understanding with engaging someone like Dr Jauncey to be part of his coaching team.. An ageing Coach like Bennett may or may not be part…"
3 hours ago
More…