We cannot afford him. He is on 850k a season at dogs. We have the forwards to win a comp. We need to find an X factor in the spine or really develop Dylan.
We need more depth in our forwards, the team has gone backwards since RCG out injured.
We need to be able to rotate and rest players in high collision/effort areas.
Scott
Electric Eel > Scott GregsAugust 19, 2021 at 7:12pm
RCG, Junior, Mahoney, Brown, Papalii, Matterson, Lane, Nuikore, Kafusi, Lussick, Roache, Stone, Hipgrave, Cartwright, Greig, not to mention Makatoa ( recently played). Hughes, Hollis in development. How much forward depth do you want? Sadly our forwards have taken a hit at a crucial time with injuries but we have the depth and rotation to fill in. Chasing the collision, might not be helping. Backs are out issue, not the forwards.
Scott Gregs > Electric EelAugust 19, 2021 at 7:20pm
What quality is really in that list though and how many of them are big bodies like Props?
Not many.
Scott
Electric Eel > Scott GregsAugust 19, 2021 at 7:34pm
Are you for real or just agitating? Junior Paulo 188cm 123kg, RCG 193cm 115kg, Matto 194cm 107kg, Lane 198cm 110kg, Greig 192cm 124kg, Nuikore 188cm 106kg, Hollis 196cm 105kg, Hughes 103cm 111kg. These guys are then well balance with so called smaller ( not in reality ) players like Nathan Brown, Stone, Hipgrave etc. The game has chnaged. We have a large and athletic pack of forwards. We also have depth. We however, have a stupid game plan.
Scott Gregs > Electric EelAugust 19, 2021 at 7:39pm
We don't have the forwards to play the style Arthur wants to play.
We would have a good pack if Arthur played the forwards to their strengths.
Scott
ParraPride > Scott GregsAugust 20, 2021 at 11:26am
It's the structure and chasing the collision and front loading bs that has derailed our season..
Our forwards aren't or barely offloading anymore, our attack is lacklustre, we have no shape defensively!
Clearly something is going on and the players are affected..
Scott Gregs > ParraPrideAugust 20, 2021 at 12:48pm
I agree Pride, for us to have maintained our form we needed greater depth in those high collision positions.
For years we have relied on RCG and Paulo in terms of Props but we have realistically needed more to cover them.
People can argue that we have plenty of forwards but most of them are back rowers.
"Who is not phased? nobody who has an understanding of what he offers, which means it is not the coaches.
Eli republishing this shit is what we have talked about before!"
"Don't get me wrong I want Lomax to stay, but if he wants out "there's the door". Same goes for anyone that doesn't want to be here or can get a better deal elsewhere."
"100%. Most of us have been glued to computers for decades and smartphones (AI). Yet, I wouldn't excuse or blame the computer for our own decisions, and suspect there's more than a button-touch of human decision-making behind it. That's not wholly…"
Replies
We cannot afford him. He is on 850k a season at dogs. We have the forwards to win a comp. We need to find an X factor in the spine or really develop Dylan.
Yep
Explain why dogs are shit. People before Dean Pay really fucked up their salary cap.
We need more depth in our forwards, the team has gone backwards since RCG out injured.
We need to be able to rotate and rest players in high collision/effort areas.
Scott
RCG, Junior, Mahoney, Brown, Papalii, Matterson, Lane, Nuikore, Kafusi, Lussick, Roache, Stone, Hipgrave, Cartwright, Greig, not to mention Makatoa ( recently played). Hughes, Hollis in development. How much forward depth do you want? Sadly our forwards have taken a hit at a crucial time with injuries but we have the depth and rotation to fill in. Chasing the collision, might not be helping. Backs are out issue, not the forwards.
What quality is really in that list though and how many of them are big bodies like Props?
Not many.
Scott
Are you for real or just agitating? Junior Paulo 188cm 123kg, RCG 193cm 115kg, Matto 194cm 107kg, Lane 198cm 110kg, Greig 192cm 124kg, Nuikore 188cm 106kg, Hollis 196cm 105kg, Hughes 103cm 111kg. These guys are then well balance with so called smaller ( not in reality ) players like Nathan Brown, Stone, Hipgrave etc. The game has chnaged. We have a large and athletic pack of forwards. We also have depth. We however, have a stupid game plan.
We don't have the forwards to play the style Arthur wants to play.
We would have a good pack if Arthur played the forwards to their strengths.
Scott
It's the structure and chasing the collision and front loading bs that has derailed our season..
Our forwards aren't or barely offloading anymore, our attack is lacklustre, we have no shape defensively!
Clearly something is going on and the players are affected..
I agree Pride, for us to have maintained our form we needed greater depth in those high collision positions.
For years we have relied on RCG and Paulo in terms of Props but we have realistically needed more to cover them.
People can argue that we have plenty of forwards but most of them are back rowers.
Yours truly,
Scott
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 7 Next