Dally M Voting

Something that has been bugging me for a while is how seriously flawed the voting is on the Dally Ms. Gutherson saved 4 tries in the first half on and over the line. I believe this trumps anything I saw from Papenhausen on Thursday. Brett Morris scored three tries untouched which were laid on for him mostly by Keary who had 3 try assists yet Morris got 3 points and Keary got 0. Perhaps they should look at a panel of players that vote on every game. I know this is subjective, but maybe a panel could eliminate the absolute howler.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Papenhausen fake 2 head knocks giving Melboune a good rest and didnt go to the HIA (head injury assessment) tests off the field.

    That was impressive 

     

    • Especially since Storm crucified Sivo for milking last time we played in the regular season

      • Bellyache went ballistic that game

         

         

  • Yep, I couldn't believe Gutho didn't score points too.

  • Agree, flawed system full of bias.

  • Totally agree the voting in the DallyMs need a tweak, but I will say this so many Parra players could have got votes, and Girdler a former back picked all backs too, its like an ex prop picking forwards in a team that excelled, did Papynhausen get a vite because he tried hard, is that a thing now, I don't think he was even melbournes best

  • Papa house didn't do anything against us. Did he get Dally M points?

    • This reply was deleted.
      • I wouldn't even say he was the best player for Melbourne. I thought Welch was Thier best

  • This reply was deleted.
    • Seems that way already Slug

  • The only way the Daly M's can work is for every player on the field to be scored. Gutho was dead set ripped off last year.

    What's with the media and the Eels bashing. Gutho winks at a team mate and it's the biggest issue in the game but papenshittenhousen takes 2 dives and there is no mention of it.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Roy tannous posted a discussion
Grants been linked to knights and interesting,Grants open to moving to Newcastle.Just rumors at this stage but if it gets bigger and bigger.Knights can't afford him with ponga and brown on over a mill and others taking a lot of the cap.So what does…
13 minutes ago
Gucci replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"The only issue I have is the head knocks because he puts himself in the strangest positions for a big man sometimes. But majority of his long term injuries were inflicted by other players in tackles for the past two seasons."
1 hour ago
Mathew Clarke replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"Great news on all 3. I'm suprised many don't think Moretti is a good keep. He is just coming to age for Prop forwards (Mid 20's) and runs some great lines. I think he needs to have Williams show him the ropes and Luca, Teacum and Tuivaiti need to…"
1 hour ago
Yehez replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"Slightly surprised at Moretti considering we have lots of forwards coming through. But at the same time, I have sensed him slightly going another level in our improved post origin performances.
All in all good news. Tuivati especially needs to be…"
1 hour ago
More…