You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"If Carty had a broken rib three weeks is not enough time off , takes six's weeks to repare and taking needles to play is not on ."
"Gutho is a decent player albeit not fast nor the most skilful but he gives it his all each week. Don't mind him taking to refs but it does not always do much. I just wish our other forward can't played with his intensity each week. "
"Gutho moves to 14. He can play 1,6, & 9. Look at the Storm, Panthers, they have a bench player that can cover those positions.
Gutho has all the skill, all the heart, just not the knees, speed or power. In a reduce capacity Gutho would be massive at…"
Gutho has all the skill, all the heart, just not the knees, speed or power. In a reduce capacity Gutho would be massive at…"
Replies
It's a no from me. Very injury prone poor guy
No thanks - injury prone
No
Hell. No.
Got punted from the Broncos because he wasn't up to grade. Then was punted from the Roosters for the same reason. The. Went to the worst team in the comp and couldn't make the grade.
Copley is NOT the caliber of talent we should be looking to improve our roster with.
Dean Whare is the guy I'd be looking to take off Penriths hands.
He has a player option I think Penrith are to let him walk if they are keen to keep a guy like Naiden who is younger and cheaper.
For me Whare is a step in replacement for Michael Jennings and if you ask me is as good defender and attacker.
Only thing I'm doing diligence on is his injury situation,outside of that your getting an international centre.Never understood why Manly let this guy go all those years ago and I can see why Gould targeted this guy as a long term proposition at Penrith.
Agree with Coryn, Whare is a like for like replacement with Jennings although slightly slower and more injury prone. Great clubman, family man, excellent reader of a game and defensively very strong. He would come with some of the money being picked up by panthers as they try and lock down Staines and co....
I just read that Brent Naden is yet to be approached by the Panthers to re-sign...
With Cleary dropping him in the Grand Final, that would be the perfect opportunity to swoop in and pick up a decent promising centre. Certainly better than any of the options I've seen so far.
The Eels should be looking at making a play for Stephen Crichton from the Panthers. A bit of an ask but come Nov 1 we should at least make contact. Him and Waqa would be one hell of an attacking centre combo.
No way. He is average at the best of times and injured the rest of the time.
No not quite up to it especially at 29
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next