I have read many a comment on Brad Arthur on various platforms and see the division is real. The unicorn fan, the realist, the visionary and then the unyielding loyalist who follow the club no matter what is dished up.
So lets get a genuine take on our own site and see the numbers whether to extend or not.
Below, simply state YES or NO with only a small comment so as to not lose the context of our thread.
And Sorry Brissy ... I know you were once an avid Eel supporter, but to come on here as a Dolphin supporter and throw shade on some of the 1EE ppl you disagree with is seriously taking the piss, opinionate if you will, but being another team supporter, show some respect, as it tire very quickly .... said without prejudice of course. An example of your recent comment is "Calling one STUPID".
Only Parra supporters can vote lol.
I shall start - No Too many deficiencies to name, such as poor selection, bench and rotation and the agenda of promoting his son into our top 30 and 17 - sorry Cyborg.
Replies
Nope.
F off and take any other knobs who like taking the club for ransom every few years.
Nothing to losers
He's past his due by date, we need fresh ideas and young blood
Im needing to sit down and think about this one when I get home . It kinda hinges on what happens with Moses for me I think .
my first thoughts are no , but i also have to weigh up who's available or coming available . If I had to choose between BA and Barrett im saying extend BA for 20 years . If there's someone available that I know will clean out and import some fucking talent , see ya B-Rad .
Issue is there are no candidates in coaching that jump out, only one or two every 3-4 years. Like Todd Payten, Craig Fitzgibbon and Cameron Ciraldo. Even then, there are no guarentees they will work out.
Then you have say Des Hasler, would he work? Again no guarentees. At this stage BA proved his worth making a GF, i am happy to let it ride its course for 2023 at least.
LB no one thought that Hopgood would make the impact he did with us in such a short time.People have a way of surprising you.
Yes - but I don't believe any contract extension is necessary today. I can't see a reason for it. People who don't think BA is a good coach have short memories.
Well said Muttman.
BA is contracting until the end of the year. If we make the top 4 and/or make another GF, by all means, extend him then.
If he's only contracted until end of this year then a decision is very much needed to be made asap, I can't see any coach or player waiting until September to see if he has a job.
A team like Newcastle , Dragons , Etc would already be offering him plenty of numbers with zeros behind them on paper if that was the case.
I see no need to extend unless we are competing with someone else....in which case bring it on.
I also do not accept what you said about Brissy, he has more passion for his support of Parra than many of the seagulls that come on here "shit and fly off".
You just cannot make rules about who you follow!! Your arrogance in extreme!
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 9 Next