Back row stocks 2011

Hey guys, i know we have lost Mateo for 2011 but with the news that Manakufoa is almost certain to sign with us, Lee Te Mari in good form for wenty and the emergence of Justin horo in the top grade, our back row stocks look healthy for 2011, solid depth. I was one of the people who was excited at the possibility of signing luke odonell however with the below back rowers which will be at our disposal next year, i would be grooming a prop from the lower grades and splashing out on a solid hooker or half back with any left over money. What do you guys think?

 

 

Back row:

 

Hindmarsh

B Smith

Shackleton

Lee Te Mari

Manase Manakufoa

Justin Horo

Brendan Oake

 

 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • well all the profiles iv seen of him have stated him as a Second row/prop so i placed him in the list of potential back rowers as he would be able to fill a position in the back row and played back row back at souths. Shackleton has also played chunks of first grade games as a prop but i have also put him in the list as he is primarily a back rower.

    Yes you could also also add danny howard and pat O'hanlon in there although the point of my post was to highlight the depth of our back row stocks but also more to highlight the quality of them, the players i have mentioned besides probably Horo have all had quite a bit of first grade expirience now. You dont want to be throwing i alot of rookies in that position as they tend to prove defensive liabilities within their breaking into first grade..
  • how about kevin rudd?
  • Oake, Te Mari nor Horo are yet signed for next year as far as I know. I expect we'll keep Horo but I have my doubts about Brendan. We do seem intent on pissing off all our local juniors at the moment.
  • N Hindmarsh B Smith S Shackleton P O'Hanlon J Horo and maybe a new face? i dont think i want someone who cant make cowboys side but.
  • That looks like a pretty thin back row IMO.

    Especially of Shak takes a good 6 months to find form after such a major injury.
  • Not an impressive list IMO. Smith injury prone. Hindy in his zimmer frame. Shack a year out of footy and some hacks that cant make the vb Cup semis !! Please !

    and some fool who cant make the Cowboys line up

    Need to resign Horo he and Mannah are the bright spots in 2010. PS does anyone realise we cant score points !! Its not our forwards
    • (GOlling) ...Firstly, you have no idea champ... Hindy is a phenomenal player and his off the ball stuff is unbelievable if you actually watch parra play... and its all about balance.

      Secondly... You cant just say it has nothing to do with our forwards and that we are simply not scoring points. If your forwards arent dominating and getting a roll on, they can not create space for the halves and backs to play some footy.

      Also, Look at the teams like the dragons, manly and melbourne for eg, who have good and dynamic back rowers.. they are the ones who create tries too eg B Creagh poking his head out on the fringes of the ruck and getting the offload away to link with his centres and winger. Back rowers create alot of tries in modern football. Wake up to yourself..
  • Chuk firstly I have my view you have yours !

    Then can I point out to you the massive inconsistency in your blog. You start by telling me how brilliant Hindy is off the ball in defence and I agree with you 100%. My point is he cant hit it up and he runs the ball forward as if he is using a zimmer frame.

    You go on to talk about dynamic backrowers and how they create a lot of tries !!!! Well guess what pal Hindy aint doing that. I really have no idea of your view other than I agree our backrowers lack punch. Other than you being a blind loyalist to our aging champ Hindy we are in 100% agreement.

    Or are you saying that list of backrowers looks good to you ?
    • If you read my WHOLE blog you would see that i also mentioned the importance of a BALANCED pack and that is what hindy gives us, you cant have all flashy creaty back rowers and nobody to do the dirty work around the middle.... That was my point, and further more was my point that our back row stocks look good because i believe we have a good mix of creative, dynamic and tough hard workers.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Trent replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"It will happen in 26 also "
52 seconds ago
Hector replied to Anthony Mara's discussion Sam Louizou to be named
"Don't forget the first one Zac Lomax Given permission to Negotiate with Rival clubs . "
1 minute ago
Trent replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"He  will be flat out playing half the season next year also they  lost brown  and kept  half the season "
1 minute ago
Poppa replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"If you were around 40 years ago you would understand that is a meaningless stat.
Sandon Smith has been dropped from the Roosters 17, sounds like a good opportunity to pounce."
4 minutes ago
More…