Parramatta Eels Supporters Website
Firstly id like to say i think Brads a very good coach, hes got plenty of good points and i respect him immensely as a man and a coach.
I think he can take us to the top 4 again this year, he will definitely take us into the 8 again, ive no worries there, i also believe hes the coach to coach us long term.
Having said that here are a few things that i see to be an issue or could be improved.
Brad has too many favs hes invested emotionally with and its clouding his vision imo..
This can be seen by the way he gives a lot of older guys 1 year extensions as a reward when they are already over the hill, those guys only fill up the top 30 and reduce the competition for spots and hunger.
In other words he needs to be more expedient and cut throat to get the best out of his playing unit.
In RL you need top get rid of dead wood fast, not give them extended contracts like the Gowers, De'goise etc
Why hire bums like Williams and Frank Pritchard? these guys are just more dead wood who clog the top 30 up.
Jane Evans haha how embarrassing for all involved, the less said about his signing the better, if thats all he can give on his debut it doesnt say much about his ticka.
All this creates a lack of real hunger, combine that with run of the mill Vavaes and Matagi and its not looking the best..
And then theres leadership, Brad just doesnt get it, rewarding an ageing player like Scott with the co captaincy along with Tim who is the worst on field captain in history is not a good idea, its not planning for the future either.
Getting run down after big leads on a regular basis is a sign of poor leadership.
Im NOT just blaming leadership but its a cog in the wheel, anybody who thinks otherwise just doesnt get it.
Theres nobody calming or steadying the ship when we start to slide, nobody putting a calm head on the lads behind the post after the other teams scored, theres no leadership, Brads had years to work this out but because hes so emotionally invested in Tim and sees all his great off the field qualities its blinded him into thinking it carries over onto the park.
I can promise you now, we will never win a comp with Mannah as capt, never.
All these guys are dead wood or very close to it.
Theres even doubts over Manus and Teps ability to offer much in attack.
Weve got too many blokes with very limited skill sets, they just arnt offering enough on the park.
Reality is we dont need just one new big bopper forward, we need 2 or 3 who can bend the line and intimidate.
In all the time Brads been here hes promoted 2 blokes up.
I agree with buying the talent in, but if youre not buying it in which we havnt this year, and if you dont promote anybody up from the lower grades, things can get stale, the competition for spots and the hunger drops off a bit, ive seen it many times.
On to our hooker situation.
Cameron King is very overrated, he gives fairly reliable service at dummy half but thats where it ends, his decision making is poor, he takes selfish options on the line, hes just not a creating or attacking rake, not to mention he cant play 80 minutes, as a hooker he adds very little in some areas, he is not the long term answer.
Bevan French gets too much love, imo he is a huge liability on the wing, the only world i can use to describe his build is weedy, hes got zero power or strength and i can tell you now, at the pointy end of the season in the big games he will be our weakest link.
He will be exploited on our line and walked over just like Luke Burt was in the ones that mattered, there is no place in my team for wingers this small.
Bev will never be the player eels fans think he will, hes a great attacking player but thats where it ends, if he doesnt cut it at FB id be letting Bev go and id be looking to buy a big strong winger, id be looking to make our team taller/bigger all over the park where possible.
Our new strips were an absolute disgrace to look at on the weekend, we looked like a dropped lemon meringue pie, how embarrassing, they looked worse than id ever imagined, just offensive to look at, hang your head in shame Bernie, what an embarrassment.
We looked like we were dressed to attend a gay sling party for seniors at a bowling club, disgraceful.
We need a purge to rid the dead wood very soon or we will continue to be the also rans, we also need to sort out the leadership issue and start planning for the future leadership wise or we will continue to have the soft underbelly we have on the park.
BLUE AND GOLD WILL NEVER FOLD!
I hope youre right mate but hes had plenty of time to bulk his legs up, its like his thighs are devoid of muscle, he just lacks power and strength and i reckon it hurts us.
No point having any winger or player who cant hold his own and Brad still protects him in defence.
My opinion here is not a result of this game, ive had the same opinion for a few years now, i think size is very very important across the park Mick.
The schueb is back - ive shed a nasty skin i had after the salary cap rubbish!
snake agree, the sides key issue is leadership, that flogging for 45 minutes saw not one leader take charge! Timmy whilst a great bloke is not tactical and Captaincy requires mongrel - smith whilst i hate him is a great competitor and leader.
French could be another sandow, ben barba, bowen, men that require protection! So i see what ur saying
arthur has been a phenomenal influence at the club in what has been the biggest period of crisis in its history - we need some future forwards, we need a leader, we need gutho back, weve made some strange decisions but i support the club 100% which isnt where i was not long ago!
Welcome back Schueb!
Brad needs to give those guys a little taste, even if its on the bench for the odd game, keep em hungry, create competition, get that hunger and fresh blood in.
Ray stones enthusiasm is infectious, give the kid a taste.
Agree with most of this Snake, he's far too loyal to some average at best players, and he's terrified of giving young blokes a go. Stone and Nuikore couldn't offer any less than Scott or Matagi. He's done a lot of good things for the club but after 5 years he's still getting the bench and interchanges wrong at times. I've been saying for Years we will never ever win a thing with Captain Soft serve in charge.
I was going to post a blog about our ageing squad and lack of young talent coming through but i'll just add it to this.
I am really concerned about our future after this season, we have an ageing squad with a few players playing on a year too long, then you add BA's recruitment strategy of buying old has been forwards without having or recruiting any decent young forwards is a recipe for future failure. In my opinion BA's biggest flaw is his lack of respect for young players, he never seems to give anyone a chance, he would rather give an old washed up player like Frank Pritchard, Tony Williams and the like a run than give a young forward the chance to prove himself, it's a young mans game ffs brad.
I can understand the need for experienced players in the first couple of years when BA took over as we were a mess but we should have started to transition by now. Every other club seems to have a couple of good young forwards coming through except the eels, maybe Stone and Nuikore are good but when will get get to find out?, you can almost guarantee they will be playing for other clubs in the next season or two.
Manly at home on a Sunday afternoon after them losing last week will be a huge step up for the Eels! To be honest I can’t see the Eels winning this game. It would have to be a huge turnaround and Brad Arthur needs to get his act together with his selections and rotation off the bench.
Tell you what in most sports you need basically a bunch of guys that do there jobs and 3-4 that do a bit more.
While it may sound like that they maybe carrying some soso talent I think it's much like that across the board in the nrl.
Its not just us that are carrying this issue.
The snake files. The truth is out there.