Does Peats captaincy talk suggest 80 minute role?

If I had to make a call I think Nathan Peats is most likely to be co-captain and I wonder if the fact that he's so in the frame, suggests that BA definitely sees him as an eighty minute hooker.

I guess he doesn't have to play hooker and he can slide back to the backrows, but 1) he won't like that and 2) we have much better backrow options.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I wouldn't like to see Peats at second row, Phil and hopefully I won't.

    I can't believe BA would take our best hooker and play him in a position to which he has no entitlement.  As you suggest, he'd be well down the pecking order for a gig in the backrow.

    I'm beginning to think that Hoppa may get a mention as vice / co-captain.

    • Just to be clear, I'm not suggesting he'll play second-row for the whole game, but rather he might dropback into a 13 role while IDG moves to hooker. I don't like that, either. I'd much rather we use our interchange to bring on a player like Pauli Pauli to give us a bit of oomph.

  • BA did say "we are lucky to be able to have IDG and Peats on the field at the same time."

  • With the new rule change and the speed of everything going on around the ruck I can't see too many hookers playing 80 minutes. Whether he goes off or to second row remains to be seen.

  • I'd argue that a good fresh hooker can give EVERY forward a dose of extra oomph.  Sure, Pauli could maybe take one hit up per set, if the ball was in the right place.  A fresh hooker could enable every play to be that little bit more crisp and dangerous, as well as shouldering an extra load of work in defense, keeping the big boppers going for longer.

  • Peats is great out of dummy half but does he have the creativity and skills to play as a ball playing forward? If so he could be used in a similar role to what Paulo tried to play last year as an extra ball player. Definitely worth considering in small spurts to mix the attack up.
  • Because of his competiveness and aggression I think Peats would be an ideal fit as Co-Captain. The only issue I have is can his body handle playing week to week 1st grade at the standard he sets. From the 8 - 10 games we saw him play last season he is as aggressive as anyone in the comp but can his body do it over 26 rounds and hopefully semi final football.

    At this point of time that's unproven territory for Peats

  • i think you will find that Tim will be captain and lead the boys and Peats will be Vice Captain and will take over when Mannah is off the field.

  • he is an 80 minute player but i think BA will use de goise as well so peats will get a rest if he doesn't slide into lock.

  • Does it really make sense to think Peats would revert to second row if IDG came on? If the idea is to give Peats a rest, sub him right off, as otherwise you've got a guy playing second row at something other than full tilt.

    Mannah has been co-captain while being subbed off like any front rower, so Peats being in the frame for co-captain tells us little about BA's plans for Peats' game-time.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Steel be with you replied to Frankie Fong's discussion A MESSAGE FROM THE FONG
"I'd say Wests Tigers and Gold Coast are more North Sydney than anything, only a way worse version. Wests Tigers have only made three finals in 23 years! and currently have the third longest finals drought in history since 1908. Gold Coast....well…"
4 seconds ago
LB replied to Frankie Fong's discussion A MESSAGE FROM THE FONG
"Not a bad claim, only thing i say is Norths only made one more GF after their 1922 title. In 77 years they made 1 GF. No minor premierships either. Souths were in same boat. 1971 was last premiership before 2014. In that time of 43 years they made…"
12 minutes ago
Frank The Tank replied to Frankie Fong's discussion A MESSAGE FROM THE FONG
"I agree wholeheartedly and life's far more important than any game. To lose someone you love under those circumstances is unthinkable.
Regarding the Eels, to be honest all Eels fans should be used to losing by now - like it or not we are fast…"
18 minutes ago
LB replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Gutho knee issues
"100% Steel. I cannot stand Luai, what he stands for as a player. But if he played for Parramatta i would defend him to the hills. Latrell if he was at Parra i would stand by him. It is just how it is. Now doesn't mean we turn a blind eye to bad…"
18 minutes ago
More…