Do we have a size problem?

There have been a lot of nice things written about the Eels pack, and they do look a very aggressive, mobile and skillful set of forwards.

However, given that our starting pack is likely to be Mannah and Matagi, Mau, Meoroa, Scott and De Gois, that's probably going to be the smallest starting pack in the competition,

Moeroa is the only guy there who is signicantly bigger than six foot or gets up around the 110kg. Without question, we're going to face up to packs that have a good 20kg on us.

Now, I don't necessarily think size is a huge issue. As long as you defend aggressively enough so that the other team doesn't get you on the back foot, you can at least hold your own. But it can be a worry if you have a forward in the other team who does early damage on a set, because you're then constantly on your heels and at risk of being rolled over. The other issue is if you're having to defend really aggressively against bigger guys, you're injury rate is going to be impacted.

Personally, I feel one of the biggest tweaks that Brad Arthur can achieve with his squad this year is to get Siosaia Vave up to starting quality. Having one big body in the defensive line for those initial collisions in every set, I feel would make a significant difference. It's a real shame that he's basically missed the pre-season, and it remains to be seen how well our forward pack can compete with some of the bigger packs they are going to encounter.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • You really thought that blog title through, let the fun begin

  • No I dont, do you?

  • Your PEOPLE tell you that

  • I think it would have been an issue in previous years, but since the introduction of reduced Interchange & the 7 tackle rule along with other tweaks, I believe the momentum has slightly swung to the mobile packs.

    The Bulldogs 2016 failure is a prime example, and apart from Fifita, the Sharks success is also tied to it's mobility.

    Sharks lanky prop Matt Prior, went from a nsw cup regular, to a grand final winning prop - work that out.
  • Pretty much sums it up for most Parra fans. Interestingly leading into round 1 last year the answer by most fans would have been no to all.
  • Only in size not in heart, bring it on
  • Snake might be best to answer this question.........

  • Plus I think you're underestimating Matagi, Phil.
    The guy is an American pit bull terrier, on steroids.
  • I remember when Brian Smith went for size above all else, buying Cannings, Stapleton, Pearson, Kaufusi..
    Great times..
    • Tank, pls don't bring up some of them. Pearson and Stapleton...nice blokes but avg

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Jim Muir replied to Hell On Eels's discussion R8 v Manly: The Rise and Fall of the Eels
"An amazing post. Thank you. It's great to get such a comprehensive and well reasoned analysis to chew over. I hope the Parra powers that be have read it and are mulling over the calls to action that need to be addressed - otherwise we could be a…"
2 minutes ago
Eli Stephens replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Jett Cleary off to NZ
"Could be as good as the big brother apparently. "
2 minutes ago
Offside replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Jett Cleary off to NZ
"Funny enough he is also eligible for the kiwis after being born there 
Imagine a Cleary v Cleary international 😂
Jet Cleary is a good player a mate of mine who works in the Penrith jr system reckons he has that something special "
12 minutes ago
LB replied to Hell On Eels's discussion R8 v Manly: The Rise and Fall of the Eels
"Around that time from Warriors last year is where we got the brain snaps from RCG and Sivo leading to long suspensions. Dylan Brown also. It seemed the makeup of the squad started to become unfocused and just seemed disregard the establishment. The…"
14 minutes ago
More…