Replies

  • In my opinion if Twal wasn't used as a pawn to trade the signing of Moses, who was a must have, not hanging onto Twal was a major mistake.

    He'll be twice as good as Alvaro.
  • Couldn't believe that we let him go at the time, and still can't believe it now.

    That's 3 guys we let go of in the space of 12 months who have immediately got into first grade at their new clubs.

    Fuimaono at souths, plus Josh Aloiai and Alex Twal at the tigers. 

    I'm pretty sure both Twal & Fuimaono played for the jnr kangaroos previously.

    I can't believe that in this day and age we are still giving "jobs for the boys" to keep their younger brother happy etc.  Frank Pritchard is one example.

  • Well BA does seem obsessed with hanging onto aging players like Mannah, Matagi, Vave, and Pritchard. Twal would be better than any of these. BA's made a number of selection and signing blunders now. It's getting to the point it could backfire big time.

    • That's exatly right EWRA.

      Why put the time, effort, money, and other recourses into developing those players if we're not going to fight tooth and nail to retain them?  Why let other clubs benefit from our efforts? 

      I really believed those days were over. I know people will say "Oh well, we can't keep them all", but come on, these are common sense decisions. We did the exact same thing with Moimoi, Hindmarsh, Cayless, and Burt. 

      Other clubs, the smart clubs, the successful clubs, they don't muck around. They'll drop club favourites in a heart beat in exchange for the next big thing. They always look to STRENGTHEN their rosters while we look to keep our roster happy by signing a brother of one of our existing players. 

      Which decision is smarter here?  Sign the next big thing from another club or retain one from our own ranks,  or keep 2 INJURY MAGNETS brothers?

  • You have to factor in price as well. Not just now but in a couple more years. We can't keep everybody, and we don't know the full situation. I'd like to think we are keeping those with the best value for the club however.
  • The biggest flaw with BA is identification and developing forwards twal and aloi should never of been released
    • Brad thinks Tim had more potential and was more valuable than both.

      I was never a Twal fan but i cant see how one would let him go and keep a dope like mannah.

  • BA has now let Twal go, playing well for tigers and Leb team, Materson who has held a place in rooster side, Fuimaono who holds a spot in souths and Aloaia at tigers. Shows he can spot talent letting these 4 go and kept re signing Kaysa and the great Joesph Paulo 2 players everyone on here said were crap and he kept perservering with. And Toupo (sorry about the spelling) for Rooters as well.

    • Did BA re-sign Paulo? And are you suggesting BA let Daniel Tupou go?
  • Twal leaving had nothing to do with Moses. He has been awesome in his appearances for Tigers. Moses was tanking and tantruming at Tigers and playing NRL. Twal wasn't.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Michael W. replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Jett Cleary off to NZ
"I suppose you're one of the idiots who wanted Sanders to hang around for 4/5 yes to get the opportunity to be a 1st grade regular."
2 hours ago
Uncle Wizards Sleeve indigenous elder He/Him replied to BEM's discussion RIP TERRY HILL
"Yup, woke = broke.   Once upon a time Thursday night meant nothing but Footy show night in most households I knew. As soon as she turned up even as a " reporter " it was doomed. It lost all credibility and you couod just tell that the show that was…"
3 hours ago
LB replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 8 Team List v Manly Warringah Sea Eagles (ANZAC Round)
"Frankie do you think they will have mural with a candle when BA is gone from the club? Perhaps place some flowers at Kellyville while whispering "We appreciate you".
Legit BA could be driving and drive onto the pathway hitting and killing one of…"
3 hours ago
fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to BEM's discussion RIP TERRY HILL
"He was a geat bloke who always had good joke or story to tell. He stood up for what he believed and always heard plenty of good stories about him helping others.
Younger fans mightn't know that he took on the league in court ending the draft for…"
3 hours ago
More…